I'm done talking about this. I'm heeding Dr. Popcak's advice and stepping away from this debate to take care of my kids.
Here are his thoughts on the matter of guilt and AP.
I did want to leave with the quote that seems to have caused so much commotion, a quote that was never meant for our eyes, BTW.
Dr. Popcak in his response to Danielle Bean:
I would agree that you cannot do AP without going to the nuthouse if you have another child every year. But the AP response would be that, unless God has somehow specifically called a person to act in a manner that is contrary to what he created the child's body to need (which would be remarkable considering Pope Benedict's assertion at Ravensburg that the Christian God is a God of order and reason who does not contradict the laws of his own creation) then it is imperative to the bonding process and the health of the mother that children be spaced about 2.5 to 3 years apart (give or take).
Notice he says GIVE or TAKE. When he says "imperative," I'm reading the words right after as being more important than the number of years given.
Some have said this would be a Catholic argument against AP because it would allegedly limit the size of the family. But a healthy couple who married in their 20's and practiced AP could easily have and properly form a family of 8 or more children before the woman's fertility ends. The Sears' did.
AP parents are just as open to life as others, they just seek to expand their families in a manner that is respectful both to the health of the mother and the well-being of their children. People who are doing Catholic AP correctly don't put themselves in the position of having to choose whose needs get met (the parent's or the children's). They adhere to the Catholic teaching on the common good which requires that each member of a community has a right to have his or her needs met but only in a manner that is respectful of the needs of everyone else in the community.
I suppose when I read this, I'm not shocked at all. Why?? Well, I guess he's sticking up for us women. He's saying that in seeking to expand our families we have to consider the health of the mother AND the well being of the children already here. And he's pointing out that 2.5-3 year spacing normally does that. But of course anyone is free to space them shorter or even longer. He's not demanding that ALL FAMILIES do this. He's pointing out that, practically speaking, this spacing respects both mother and living children. And this in response to the objection that trying to do AP AND have children close together would send some to the nuthouse.
*****************************
Now for the funny part, here are my children's spacing:
Isabelle is 2.5 years older than Anna.
Anna is 18 mos. older than Sophia.
Sophia is 15 mos.older than Kolbe.
***Craig almost loses his wife to the nuthouse at this juncture. ***
Kolbe is 2.5 years older than Catherine.
Catherine would have been 2.5 years older than our baby in Heaven on January 19th.
I guess I don't feel offended because I see how the spacing helped me to be a better mom. But of course, if someone can be a good mom with less spacing, then you should really read into the qualifier (more or less).
I think he's a lone voice in the Catholic community who would have families believe that being a good Catholic family involves NOT using NFP and having as many children as possible. I think discerning each new baby is good. And discerning if mother is physically and mentally ready is alright. I don't know how else to discern other than by using NFP.
I might seem very defensive but I'm also battling this same war here at home. I've met a wonderful group of women and I enjoy spending time with them every month. But they are of the opinion that NFP should be for extreme cases only. And I disagree. I embrace the whole notion of Integral Procreation.
And so I feel relieved and comforted, while I'm sure Dr. Popcak is walking through fire coals right now, to hear that it is imperative that I bond with my children and stay healthy. The footnote for me is that this can usually be achieved with 2.5-3 year spacing (more or less).
Now you ladies can see how twisted my brain is. This is honestly how I'm understanding him. Maybe I'm wrong. But I choose not to swallow the green pill (or whatever the color is from the Matrix). LOL!!!
Have a great week. Craig comes home tonight so I probably won't be around. And poor guy, I've been talking his ears off on the phone all day. He agrees it was a tough year after Kolbe was born. That was the year I bought our first baby swing!! LOL!! Not very AP appropriate. LOL!! That was also the year we started homeschooling. What a year!! But I wouldn't change anything!
I am who I am BECAUSE of what I've been through, not despite it.
-Dr. Kenneth Craycraft